| Rank | Player | College | Value |
| 1 | Cam Ward | Miami | 1st |
| 2 | Jaxson Dart | Mississippi | 1st-2nd |
| 3 | Shedeur Sanders | Colorado | 2nd |
| 4 | Quinn Ewers | Texas | 2nd |
| 5 | Jalen Milroe | Alabama | 2nd |
| 6 | Will Howard | Ohio State | 3rd-4th |
| 7 | Tyler Shough | Louisville | 4th |
| 8 | Riley Leonard | Notre Dame | 4th-5th |
| 9 | Dillon Gabriel | Oregon | 4th-5th |
| 10 | Kyle McCord | Syracuse | 4th-5th |
| 11 | Tommy Mellott | Montana State | 6th |
| 12 | Cam Miller | North Dakota State | 7th |
| 13 | Kurtis Rourke | Indiana | 7th |
| 14 | Max Brosmer | Minnesota | UDFA |
| 15 | Brady Cook | Missouri | UDFA |
| 16 | Taylor Elgersma | Laurier | UDFA |
| 17 | Seth Henigan | Memphis | UDFA |
| 18 | Payton Thorne | Auburn | UDFA |
| 19 | Ethan Garbers | UCLA | UDFA |