| Rank | Player | College | Value |
| 1 | Andraez “Greedy” Williams | LSU | Early 1st |
| 2 | Deandre Baker | Georgia | 1st |
| 3 | Byron Murphy | Washington | 1st |
| 4 | Justin Layne | Michigan State | 1st-2nd |
| 5 | Rock Ya-Sin | Temple | 2nd |
| 6 | Julian Love | Notre Dame | 2nd |
| 7 | Trayvon Mullen | Clemson | 2nd-3rd |
| 8 | David Long | Michigan | 2nd-3rd |
| 9 | Amani Oruwariye | Penn State | 2nd-3rd |
| 10 | Jojuan Williams | Vanderbilt | 2nd-3rd |
| 11 | Lonnie Johnson | Kentucky | 3rd |
| 12 | Isaiah Johnson | Houston | 3rd-4th |
| 13 | Jordan Brown | South Dakota State | 3rd-4th |
| 14 | Corey Ballentine | Washburn | 4th |
| 15 | Sean Bunting | Central Michigan | 4th |
| 16 | Hamp Cheevers | Boston College | 4th |
| 17 | Kris Boyd | Texas | 4th |
| 18 | Kendall Sheffield | Ohio State | 5th |
| 19 | Iman Marshall | USC | 5th |
| 20 | Jimmy Moreland | James Madison | 5th |
| 21 | Savion Smith | Alabama | 5th |
| 22 | Montre Hartage | Northwestern | 6th |
| 23 | Mark Fields | Clemson | 6th |
| 24 | Brian Peavy | Iowa State | 6th |
| 25 | Jamel Dean | Auburn | 6th |
| 26 | Jordan Wyatt | SMU | 7th |
| 27 | Mazzi Wilkins | South Florida | 7th |
| 28 | Clifton Duck | Appalachian State | 7th |
| 29 | Ryan Pulley | Arkansas | 7th-UDFA |
| 30 | Xavier Crawford | Central Michigan | 7th-UDFA |
| 31 | Rashad Felton | South Carolina | 7th-UDFA |
| 32 | Keisean Nixon | South Carolina | 7th-UDFA |
| 33 | Ken Webster | Mississippi | UDFA |
| 34 | Jamal Peters | Mississippi State | UDFA |
| 35 | Derrick Baity | Kentucky | UDFA |
| 36 | Tim Harris | Virginia | UDFA |
| 37 | Isaiah Wharton | Rutgers | UDFA |
| 38 | Ka’dar Hollman | Toledo | UDFA |
| 39 | Donnie Lewis | Tulane | UDFA |
| 40 | Blace Brown | Troy | UDFA |